Brooklyn brownstone Sharktooth
3 / 26

The photo that hangs over the couple’s dresser is extremely sentimental. “On one of our first dates, we figured out that our families had rented the same house in Cape Cod when we were kids, weeks apart,” says Garner. “About a year ago, while digging through a pile of discarded photos at Brimfield, I found a picture of the very same house, shot in the early 1950s. On the rug is my 12-year-old whippet Nia. In the winter she’ll lay in this spot motionless for a few hours while the sun passes by.”